rangerovers.pub
The only place for a coil spring is up Zebedee's arse
Member
offline
83 posts

So the exhaust for the 4.2L and the 5.0L are the same? I could probably find some decent used ones here if they are the same. The older 4.2L are getting scarce around here but 5.0L are easier to find.

So why the Maf? Due to age? Or simply to hard to determine if it is reading out of spec. (sort of a preventative measure).

I think by jubilee clip you are referring to what we would call a hose/screw/gear clamp. But I have no idea what "ally" is.

Easily? LOL They put these things together like an F1 car, except the forgot that it only takes 2 people about 5 min to remove the body to gain access. No special tools required.
I did notice that. Are these pipes available separately in the UK? I looked on lr parts direct and they are not shown separately. It appears they come with the manifold or the catalytic converter. Neither of which is anywhere close to an economical repair here. Matter of fact the cost of replacing the cats at dealer price exceeds what I originally paid for the truck.
I do have the ability to make new ones myself but getting the alignment right is particularly difficult due to warpage while welding. So I would prefer to just replace them.

Yea, we have something similar. Most dont stick for more than a few months if not prepared properly. Biggest problem is that i can barely get my little hand in there let alone a tool. Wire wheel, grinder no chance of getting it in there. I will see what can do today. It will only be temporary but good enough to prove the issue.
I also have the option of putting more weld on it. Might get me thru to winter when I wont be driving it anyway.
Same as the previous person with lots of hope and good intentions. LOL
Unless I can figure out how to see thru my tools and body parts LOL

I did do a visual for exhaust leaks when I first got the truck. And they dont make enough noise to hear. When I saw the welds I did remember them. But the telltales are not visible except in the pics. Even the holes are not visible in the pics only the telltales. Getting the phone in there for you guys meant I got angles and detail that no one would never see. Im not sure the stick with tissue would show these. Looking at the fueling traces the trims only show and issue once the revs are up with engine load after is settles into cruise. There may not be enough leakage to show up at idle.
I hadnt thought of the silicone. Might work for a few days to test. Ultimately they will have to be removed for me to repair them properly. There is no way to get anything in there to work with. I can think of 2 reasons that someone has done this.
1 They blew holes the pipe with a torch while trying to heat the sensor bungs.
2 Blowing holes using the welder instead to try to locally heat the bungs
Either way It was an on the truck repair where the welder is blindly stuck in there with the hopes of hitting the right spot and not burning thru. Since you cant see anything around the welder Then you just keep building until the hole goes away, Since you cant see where you are welding you have no control of where and how much you are putting on. Works for a while but blows out a few years later.
Im guilty of this myself, but a pinhole made no difference years ago. I have some pin holes in my winter truck with dual wide band sensors and it doesnt care, I didnt even set a mil when the downstream sensor fell out.

And to top it all off. I THINK WE HAVE SUCCESS.
I crawled under the truck to look at the O2 sensors. I found some crap welding on the pipe and the O2 bung that does not look original. It appears that someone has changed the upstream sensors since I can see wrench marks on them and either the bungs spun in the pipe (doubtful) or someone over heated the pipe with a torch and then attempted to weld the holes up. So I decided to take some pics for you guys. After some effort to get my phone in there to question this and get some pics for you, upon reviewing the pics I spotted the telltales of tiny pinholes in weld on each side that are hidden from view. And the bank1 side is slightly larger than bank 2
I have read that these pinholes can cause the P0171 and P0174 lean MILs.
Pic here.
Bank 1 (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PcmpetTjJSRtsTDsOGYjZQY-tjkjzX3f/view?usp=sharing) A little black smile near the bottom of the weld just above the flange

Band 2 (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Dhl-dsXqUyUJABrlr_yLFRpWX6j_ZITs/view?usp=sharing) I couldnt get the camera around the backside of the weld
This one is a little harder to see. There is a small black spot on the left of the weld right at the edge of the weld with the telltale puff heading away from the weld. and a small black spot above the weld where someone struck an arc while not being ale to see properly

Looks like i will be removing these for repair and/or replacement.
What are the odds of not destroying the O2 sensors during this process?

So I spent the day attempting to get to my fuel filter. And found a few interesting things. I must have gotten a good one not built on a Mon or Fri. My fuel filter had the manufactures seal still on the access holes on both sides. I also found that there are 2 wires on the bottom of the filter that when disconnected turn set the fuel gauge to empty. Both wires appear to be isolated from each other. I wonder if there is a switch in the filter that sets the gauge to empty if the filter becomes plugged.
I also found a date on my MAF sensor and it is the original made in Germany part with an 08 year on it.
pics of filters
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1TXxgCue4pR6VzLQmewZq4vhQObIEQxL7/view?usp=sharing)
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1-7LMmQKjOyW43gWkgqMW-r8PT-R4XQAy/view?usp=sharing)

Lpgc
Here are the logs you suggested. I let it idle for about 5 min and then drove at different speeds with a few hills for good measure and without cruise.
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gGn3xlvCLwtCL9uyUvxO9MzXJwXfzEQN/view?usp=sharing)

I also did a maf log as well for interest.
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1pqW-K7w2iJvczzIjGXKTnL55ou48j3JZ/view?usp=sharing)

So i read something about oiled kK&N air filters fouling MAF sensors. Since the air filter i just replaced was of this type. I cleaned the MAF with rubbing alcohol and went for a rip. Logged it from the end of my driveway. Engine was already up to min temp when i started logging. I goofed and logged both the equivalence ratios but missed fuel pressure.
File is a pdf, may give you a better look. Sometimes this works but not always. If this format is preferred let me know. Ignore anything left of 0, Im not sure why my tool does this.
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sfPyjiuMdKU2PkrXWmU0sauC6JpkwDGj/view?usp=sharing)

I will try to remember to get those traces tomorrow evening on my way home. I was starting to think I should include rpm or load on some of these traces just for reference. 6 months from now they wont mean much to me if I cant remember what the conditions were.
I have a couple of dumb questions for to gain some more understanding
1 I have read on other posts where guys have said they changed some o2 sensors and that solved the problem. Claiming they were old and probably reacting slower than they should. Rate of response, I think was the term. Is this possible? ie reading lower and/or slower. I need a little more than someone's parts cannon to go down that rabbit hole.
2 Relating to question1 If I understand this right, disconnecting an o2 sensor should cause the ecu to go into some sort of safe mixture/map mode (open loop??? using cold mixture settings). Would this then be visible on the ignition timing, injector pulse width, fuel pressure, etc. traces for comparison. And also visibly on the plugs as a richer setting?

Those heavy anomalies are going downhill while using cruise control. It does this when the throttle is closed until the speed is reduced to a certain point. (quite slow or until brakes/throttle applied). My interpretation of this, is that they want the fuel pump to have reserve pressure in case of full throttle application. This makes me believe it is a pressure command to the pump control unit. For that reason Im also in most cases trying to do all my data recording on the same stretch of road for comparison purposes while physically watching things at other times.

I will see what I can get. I am limited to max 8 traces at once and this does slow down the read rate but should still be good enough. On Sunday when i go to town I will get some varying conditions. Should I be monitoring this stuff when the engine is stone cold as well? I would think they would have allowed some extra fudge factor for cold conditions.
One more dumb question I see on other sites some discussion about ecu reprograming/updating. Is this something i should get done? If so dealer item i assume? It has about 230 000km on the clock.

Just a note. I still have not seen the lean code since i last noted it in this thread.

Actually the fuel pump doesnt look that bad. It does follow the fuel pump percentage line. This is also a PWM controlled pump, so the pressure will go up and down according to what the controller gives it. What does bother me is the amt of sawtooth in the pattern considering the smoothness of what i assume is either the PWM signal itself or the commanded signal to the control unit. Also the manual calls for 45 psi at idle, It might be averaging 45 psi but it falls to as low as 41psi. and not smooth.

FYI
So just for sh#ts and giggles, (Canadian slang for -- because I can) I decided to test if my EVAP system is operating correctly. I loosened my fuel cap after driving. It took 3 starts to set, but it did set an evap MIL. It even stated on the dash to check my fuel cap and that i had a large evap leak.
So that eliminates another possibility of a vacuum leak in that system

I wondered about that. At least i have some sort of data to look back at when this fault finally shows up again. Which im pretty sure it will..

Lpgc
Bear with me I am old enough to remember carburetors, points ignition and days long before electronic fuel injection. Fuel injection is still a new learning curve for me. I only have 2 options, learn new technology or take it in to Land Rover and hand over my first born male child, The latter of which does not appeal to me.
I have only uploaded pics of data snippets. Equivalence ratios are included. Some of the data I am looking at may not be relevant since I have about 6 different ways to read information from O2 sensors. Im not entirely sure what data I am looking at yet. Also I am old and my eyes are not as good as they used to be. Sometimes i have to look at it 3 times to realize what I am looking at on these tiny cell phone screens. ( And as with most of us, I can shoot my mouth off before fully understanding it). At this point I am certain this is not a vacuum leak and fairy certain it is not a sensor issue. The equivalence ratios are very close to the commanded ratio. Fuel pump pressure (to me since I have no reference) appears to be slightly weak but reasonable. The fuel trims seem high to me albeit Im not entirely sure what is considered normal. I am trying to follow the general procedures for this code. Vacuum leaks test first. Passed. Check sensors and look for anomalies. So far so good.
Other than fuel trims all seems to be fine. I have put some data up for viewing. If you would like me to look at something specific, If it is within my means I would be happy to try to obtain it for evaluation.
I do believe It is sailing close to the wind on both banks, at this point I am mostly data logging to build a picture of it should look like. So that when the MIL shows up I have somewhat of a baseline. And I can then figure out where to look further without driving myself into the poor house by just throwing parts at it.
As i understand it, the O2/ lambda controls/adjusts fuel trims until the fuel trims exceed their working window. Which then sets in my case a lean MIL.
Things that affect the lambda. Vacuum leaks, bad O2 sensor (which should set another/different MIL) and fuel delivery.
Have I understood this correctly? If not please correct me

Injector cleaning fluid used was Seafoam added to the fuel tank at the highest recommended strength
Swapping parts has crossed my mind but O2 sensors are particularly tricky. Quite often they fail simply by removing them. And im not at all convinced the O2 sensors have anything to do with this. They appear to be doing their job and compensating for something. Besides when they fail they are supposed to set a MIL. I did some more logging today on the fuel pump pressures and fuel trims. The long term fuel trims are near the top end of what I understand is acceptable, 16%for bank 1 and 13% for bank 2 at 110 kmh cruise. With bank1 compensating slightly more than bank2 on deceleration and acceleration. I will upload some more data pics.
In all the data logging I have done the only thing that really stands out (as I learn how to use this tool of course) is the both long term fuel trims. If both are higher than they should be with I suspect bank1 setting the MIL when it crosses the threshold, and bank2 not far behind. To me that seems to indicate fuel starvation but on both banks. Since the fuel enters the rail near the pressure sender at cyl 8 then crosses at the front of the engine to bank1 cyl 1 It makes sense that slightly low pressure/flow would cause bank1 to cross the threshold before bank2. And just to make things interesting, its sits just under the threshold until things get cold.
Am i making sense or is it beginning to sound like im overthinking it and spewing gibberish?

Yea Im not entirely sure what im looking at. The other weird thing about this is that bank 1 is actually the problem bank and the one associated with the MIL code.
Some of the pattern may have to do with the data rate on my scan tool/analyzer. .
I still think this comes down to a fuel delivery issue since it does not affect all the cyl on one bank
Still thinking about some ideas to test this theory.