Im also curious if the oil manufacture said anything about running fully synthetic oils in a hydraulic flat tappet engine.
Choice of oils is really up to you. Marine technology was years behind automotive at that time. Im not sure its even possible to run a boat at stochiometric ratios since they are under full load at all times. You should definitely run oil with ZDDP in it. I run high mileage blended oils 10w30 with ZDDP additives in my marine 305 chev.
A word on the dipsticks. My boat has 2 dipsticks. One is the oil change dipstick which runs down under the oil pan and connects to the actual drain hole. The 2nd is on the other side just like a car into the oil pan. My oil change dipstick does not read the same as the one in the oil pan. It does not self level with the oil when i compare them. It always reads full. Even when it is low. Why? I dont know. I can only speculate that the dipstick may not let air in and holds a vacuum on top of the oil. Or the surface tension and skin friction in the tiny tube is to much to self level. If you have the option i recommend you get an automotive one and instal it.
It might take a bit with Christmas and all that, but I will let you know what I find
I tried swapping the solenoids from one to the other with no change. Unfortunately thats not an option with the cam sensors. I could however take the sensor out of the good Rover to test the signal. BUT:
You got me thinking about the phaser comment, and I remember noticing an anomaly while doing the timing. Before and after resetting the cam timing i noticed that when i turned the engine over the exhaust camshaft would push the intake cam at a certain points and the chain would become slack on the side that should stay tight. However during the rest of the rotation the chain was fiddle string tight. So when i retimed it and saw the loose chain again i simply pushed the guide so the tensioner moved to the next stop. That seemed to solve the issue.
Now that i have spent days watching utube vids on the phasers and learning how the system works. I suspect that the phaser was not locking properly and allowing the exhaust cam to push the intake causing the chain to loosen. And now it is timed in the wrong position which is why its throwing the correlation code.
I also found out that the engine has been replaced when is got into the job. Found a stock number on the front of the timing cover that is not supposed to be there. It is varnished on the top of bank 1 but not equally varnished on bank 2. It also appears that someone may have been in there already since the gaskets were not fully crushed like they should be for the age of the engine. This may have something to do with the phaser being out of time.
So... it looks like Im going back in. At least it will be easier this time now that I know what Im doing. I will open up the phaser to see what i find and decide from there if I clean and reinstall it or replace the lot.
No i did not. Just the sticky tensioner. Chains and guides were all left in place and looked good. I did retime the cams. I do wonder if that is the case. How do i tell if the phaser is trash?
What i dont understand and am trying to figure out is what the signals mean. With only on sensor per bank i would have thought that if the cam sensor is incorrect that the vale timing would also change. but that does not seem to relate. Its like it defaults to a single sensor and changes the timing on both cams together. If you compare the signals from the good Rover to the bad one the cam timing never moves 9 degrees like the questionable signal indicates. It only moves 0-0.4 degrees. Even the cam timing angles only move a few degrees. So I wonder if 9 degrees is even possible without catastrophic engine damage. Also when i unplugged the cam sensor the questionable signal only drops to 5 degrees and not to 0.
Could this be electrickery like a bad ground or something. I am not getting a cam sensor fault only the correlation fault. And also no chain noise since retiming the engine.
Purchased another 08 supercharged RR for cheap about 2 years ago. Did not move but ran well with crankshaft correlation fault. Front driveshaft broke, easy fix. Correlation fault, not so much. I did hear the chain rattle occasionally, But I decided it was too good to just save for parts, so in we go. Main timing chains were tight, secondary chains looked good as well. Tensioner on bank 1 stuck in collapsed position during a second look 3 days later. Replaced it and retimed the engine. Runs even better now but i still have a correlation fault. I then swapped the timing solenoids to the opposite banks to see if the fault moved with the solenoid, but it did not.
Got my gap tool out and did some comparisons with the other Rover.
"Intake variable camshaft timing" on both banks reads within 5 degrees per bank on both Rovers. "Actual inlet variable valve timing" on the good Rover both banks are the same (0-0.4). On the faulty Rover bank 2 matches the good Rover (0-0.4) but bank 1 reads 9-11 degrees.
Does this point to a faulty camshaft position sensor?
Attached are the graphs that i took from each vehicle.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1uu8KleuSBdLJXQyMiadj7cq0-FLidDDB/view?usp=sharing
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DqGWNU90F1wxbjdkeqgwetMbEDuHghjv/view?usp=sharing
UPDATE:
The truck has been running great, no Mil light.
Data log from last wed with the new Maf sensor.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/12HHfxZqBgnBm-A1zdWrmOHUCM-p15tYJ/view?usp=sharing
I installed the old sensor for a few days as requested and the LFTs seemed to become somewhat inconsistent, Friday they were high around 10, Sunday they were only slightly above normal and today they went up to 11-13 during cruise. Interestingly they never got as high as they were before the sensor was replaced. Which could be just not enough mileage yet. It does not seem to have proper throttle response with the old sensor. It feels slightly lame at times usually when passing cars. It feels like it takes more throttle to make things happen. But that could also just be in my head.
I do have some data logs if you want to see them. I will be reinstalling the new sensor tonight.
One more dumb question.
Short of actually drilling a hole in my exhaust, what should keep an eye on to see if the small exhaust leaks (in previous pics) are actually starting to cause trouble? ( Im assuming Lfts and equivalence ratios)
I plan on repairing them but would like to wait until winter when Im not driving the truck.
Ha ha refitting the old Maf... That's Brilliant! (not sarcasm) I glad I havent binned it yet. I will give it about a month and try that.
How long would you expect it to take the fuel trims to go crazy again?
It took the rush hour drive thru town and a few miles of cruise to see the results after replacing it. (Long enough for me to think I had just spent $450 for nothing)
The real test will come in fall when it gets colder and the air gets denser. But we may still get some cold spells yet. I did have the Mil pop up over the weekend before I got the new Maf.
I wish I had actually calculated my fuel mileage before changing the Maf, to see if it actually changed. Im not sure how the readout actually calculates it and how accurate they are, time will tell I guess.
I am a little disappointed though, I drove an hour+ one way, paid Land Rover dollars and was then handed a Denso Maf sensor. Which I could have purchased locally for half
the cost.
Oh well c'est la vie
Sorry for the slow update.
I got the new Maf sensor Tuesday night. So i did some logging in town before changing it
Before
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1P7uLioEd1aluSqYxnfKfkvewuUksglFg/view?usp=sharing)
After
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1F0-n0PV_FdNlk4sUieRhfmnTVwLolh-e/view?usp=sharing)
It took some time but the fuel trims did eventually come way down and I think the fuel pressure increased by a few pounds as well.
This one is after about an hour on the drive home using same road I have been doing most of my data logging on.
(https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EPTpIeFx7HYfgQrzf0WXKXcF4qtsEH0Z/view?usp=sharing)
So far I like what I am seeing, I will probably pull some plugs on the weekend to confirm this.
Maf sensor should be here tues or wed of next week
Ill see what happens. might take a few days though Its cold and crappy here still for the next few days.
Im thinking I should change the Maf anyway since it is most likely polluted with oil from the previous air filter. I need to get some exhaust gaskets anyway
Some would call that cheating. LOL (instead of trying to find everything the electrical drawing) I assume you have to cut them all regardless. Easier, faster, why not?
I dont mind buying parts once im sure they are the right ones. And this is now starting to make sense.
Ok will do
I assume you want me to log data as per your list earlier?
And I assume this should be done with engine at operating temp,
Should i do this before or after changing the Maf?
You are not cutting me off. We have eliminated every thing other than some possible very tiny vacuum leak.
I will try unplugging the injectors which in simple terms sounds like it will cause the ecu to relearn parameters based on the actual wear and tear of the engine. Effectively relearning the base fuel trims for the current condition of the engine.
As per my previous post I think I understand where we are on the trouble shooting and the Maf sensor makes sense. Also since the holes in the exhaust are downstream of the upstream sensor. I dont think they would really affect the upstream sensor readings, Which I think you mentioned are the primary drivers of the fuel trims.
Other than a decent Fluke multimeter I have no other tools available to actually check each sensor out. And without a base line it wont mean much. Im learning stuff here so Im happy. Let me know if Im getting it correct.
What? I have fuel trims for all 4 O2 sensors? How did I not see that! Getting old sucks.
Holes in the exhaust would cause the O2 sensors to report a lean condition, thus directing the ecu to add fuel. If the right amount of fuel is being added, that would show up on the spark plugs as a rich condition provided no extra air is being drawn in. But if the Maf is under reporting the amount of air. It lowers the the amount of fuel added and also lowers the actual amount of the fuel the long term trims have available. Which then creates the high readings. Because the reality is not enough fuel is being added since the sensor is under reporting. And this would then actually show up on the plugs as a lean condition similar to a vacuum leak. The Ecu then uses this along with barometric pressure, air temp, engine temp to then determine how much fuel to add and also how much fuel pressure it needs.
If I got this correct, it has not been a worthless exercise. I have actually learned the basics of the system system operates.
Davew
You do have it right. They are short pcs of pipe but the humidity and salt they use on roads here makes exhaust work difficult. Any weak parts are usually broken as soon as removal is attempted which can snowball into a lot more work. As you can see from the pics access is difficult. I didnt mean to offend, I just needed some clarification on terminology.
Environmental conditions here are different to yours. We have constant humidity except in winter and then they use salt on the roads. Because of this ally and steel here, do not play well together unless very well isolated. Any hole in the exhaust system will continue to grow at an increased rate. This area of Canada is known as the rust belt. Most vehicles wont make it past 15 years. This is not something anyone would know unless you have spent time here.
Fair enough. I like to determine and validate things first. we have eliminated almost all of other possible causes. I was coming to that conclusion as well when I seen the date on it. And when I repair the exhaust I may have to replace the O2 sensors anyway if they dont survive. At least Im not throwing parts at because Im just guessing.
Has my exhaust been changed to the 5.0L? On the JLR site it does not show that for the 4.2L exhaust